Medicare HMO vs PPO Plans: Which Is Right For You?

Each year, seniors can select from a wide variety of bundled Medicare plans that offer varying benefits, costs, and structure. 

HMO and PPO plans are two popular Medicare Advantage plans. Private insurance companies offer HMO and PPO plans to help cover healthcare-related costs. Seniors must be enrolled in Original Medicare Parts A & B to purchase one of these bundled coverages for their healthcare portfolio. 

Depending on your healthcare needs, network preferences, lifestyle and budget, certain plans will be a better fit for you than others. 

Let’s Dive Into The Differences of HMO & PPO Plans

PPO Plans

Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) are Medicare Advantage Plans administered by private insurance companies and paid by the federal government to provide Medicare coverage for eligible recipients. 

Most PPO plans come with a monthly premium that is paid along with a senior’s Part B monthly premium. Typically, there will be a set deductible for medical services received, and recipients may pay a copayment for covered healthcare services after meeting that deductible. 

Each PPO plan has an assigned network of healthcare providers, but offers its recipients the ability to see providers outside of that network (although, there may be additional costs and a separate deductible). PPO plans also allow patients to see specialists without a necessary referral.

PPO plans are offered based on service coverage areas. They include: 

Local PPOs – These plans are determined by county, and can sometimes be a region of counties predetermined by Medicare. 

Regional PPOs – These plans serve either one state or a region of states which is also predetermined by Medicare.

Once enrolled, PPO recipients will receive a new Medicare ID card that will replace their Original Medicare coverage card. This card will be used at all doctor and hospital visits. 

Why You May Prefer a PPO Plan

  • Flexibility – Seniors who prefer to have more freedom to choose their healthcare providers, including specialists, may find PPO plans more appealing than HMO plans. Although the monthly premiums are typically higher, with coverage being offered both in-network and out-of-network there are many more options for care. 
  • Extra Benefits – PPO plans often bundle an array of extra benefits that help cover additional healthcare expenses not included with Original Medicare. PPO plan recipients also have the option to purchase Part D prescription plan benefits to seamlessly bundle with their current selected coverage. 
  • Travel Benefits – PPO plans may be ideal for seniors who travel often or spend a significant amount of time away from home. They can access care from a broader range of providers across different locations compared to other plans. 
  • No Referrals Required – Unlike HMO plans, PPO plans do not require referrals to see specialists (in most cases), which allows seniors more direct access to specialized care quickly when needed. 

HMO Plans

Just like PPOs, Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) are Medicare Advantage plans that private insurance companies offer to eligible seniors. They are paid for by the federal government. 

These HMO plans may charge a monthly premium and have a set deductible that is paid on top of your Original Medicare monthly premium. However, these costs are typically significantly lower than PPO plans, and some HMO plans even pay a portion of your Medicare Part B monthly premium. 

Within typical HMO plans, you must see in-network providers to receive coverage, unless it is for an emergency treatment. HMO recipients will also need to choose a PCP (primary care provider) from that network who will provide all routine care and handle referrals for specialists and testing. 

Just like PPO plans, your HMO plan will send you a new Medicare insurance ID card that will replace your Original Medicare card and will be used for all doctor and hospital visits. 

Why You May Prefer An HMO Plan 

  • More Cost Effective –Medicare recipients with tighter budgets tend to appreciate the lower premiums and out-of-pocket costs associated with HMO plans versus PPOs and other Advantage plans.
  • Coordinated Care The centralized role of the PCP in your HMO plan allows for more streamlined and coordinated care. Recipients develop a relationship with their trusted PCP and together create an individualized healthcare plan tailored to the patient’s needs and goals. HMOs can also be appealing to seniors because it takes the guesswork out of having to find their own in-network providers. This can be especially beneficial to seniors managing multiple health conditions. 
  • Preventative Care Emphasis – HMO plans emphasize preventative care and wellness programs for seniors, and offer incentives like covered extra benefits that align with healthy lifestyles and overall well-being. 
  • Part D Prescription Plan – Just like PPO plans, HMO plans also offer the option to bundle a prescription drug plan with a senior’s selected HMO plan, making it easier to manage their healthcare portfolio. 
  • Predictable Costs – With lower premiums and copayments for in-network services, HMO plans provide more stability and when it comes to medical billing. 

Why Select an HMO or PPO Plan Vs Other Advantage Plans

Cost Effectiveness:Compared to other Medicare Advantage plans, HMO and PPO plans often have lower out-of-pocket costs, making them more financially appealing for individuals who want extra benefits and coverage but have a fixed income or budget restraints.

Convenience: By bundling Medicare coverage under one plan, it is easier for seniors to manage their healthcare portfolio and only need one Medicare ID card for all services. 

Provider Networks: While other Advantage plans may offer unique benefits, they oftentimes have more limited provider networks. HMO and PPO plans typically have broader networks, offering their recipients with more options for choosing healthcare providers. 

Personal Preference: Ultimately the choice between HMO, PPO, or other Medicare Advantage plans comes down to personal preference, lifestyle, cost and healthcare needs. Some seniors may prioritize cost savings while others prefer the flexibility to choose their team of healthcare providers. How often you visit your doctors and what treatments or procedures you may need will factor into plan choice as well. 

Seniors have many Medicare Advantage plan options to choose from, and the one that is right for you depends on your own unique healthcare needs, budget considerations, lifestyle, and personal preferences. To select a plan that aligns with your current circumstances and priorities, contact My Medicare Network (a nongovernmental entity) to speak with a licensed agent about plans that are available to you. 

*    Not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program

Ready to Start the Conversation?

Fill out the form below and we’ll be in touch shortly.
My Medicare Network